
A couple of days ago I posted about sharing information with other artists. I’ve had some interesting experiences with sharing knowledge. Some good, some bad. I’d like to think that I am the kind of person who wants other people to succeed (in the art world), especially when I find someone with extraordinary talent. When I’m inspired by someone’s artwork, it causes me to want to spread the joy. I’d like to think that there are others who feel this way too.
There are several mosaic art groups around. A few on Yahoo groups, Indiepublic, a ton on Flickr and then there is Contemporary Mosaic Art on Ning. Most of the members of CMA belong to one or more of the groups elsewhere so the people are familiar. I’ve never been afraid to share information there. The members are supportive and willing to help out newcomers. It is a very creative and constructive environment. I’m thankful it exists. (Thanks to Pam Givens for starting it!)
With all that said, I started to think more about my sharing information post. Even though Etsy is a communal space where artists and craftspeople congregate to talk about their art form, their processes and their experiences, the marketplace kinda feeds that survival of the fittest mentality. It spawns that feeling of being on the school yard again. Being picked last, having the mean girls biting at your heels. Etsy can build you up but their members will tear you down.
I don’t mean to make Etsy shoulder the whole burden here. Long before Etsy was stirring up controversy in the crafting world, eBay was out there dishing out its fair share of discontent. There are scores of forums, message boards and email lists. All of them are responsible for hosting bitchfests that foster a sense of NOT belonging. I’m not even sure if it is the marketplace that causes the problem. I think it’s the people. I think it’s human nature for people to struggle to be the top dog and unfortunately being top dog sometimes means stepping on a few toes along the way. So…is it only me that is slowly building a protective wall?
My art gallery recently removed links to their represented artists’ web pages from the gallery website. Apparently potential customers were trying to remove the middle man and go directly to the artist. Just another challenge of selling art from a brick and mortar.
My friend Coco commented that “My wall has grown to where I just dont go anywhere anymore around other artists. I can no longer share or inquire…” She’s been getting nasty mail for years from people who think that she shouldn’t be breaking plates (she sells mosaic tiles from broken china). Who are they to tell her what to do?
Another commenter uninvoked says, “How many top writers receive letters from wannabes whining to them about how hard it is and asking for the name of that particular writer’s literary agent?
I think it’s better if you just go your own way, carve your own niche, and if you see someone with genuine talent? Do what you can. In the end, its up to the individual whether s/he succeeds or not.”
Obviously there are alot of artists, writers and craftspeople who experience the “wall building effect” on some level. All of us have a few trusted friends on the web that we readily share information with and all of us are cautious with how much information we give out…and to whom.
What are your experiences or opinions? Am I just being a sourpuss?